How to Decide Which Loan to Close First: A Comprehensive Guide

Managing multiple loans can be overwhelming, especially when trying to decide which one to close first. Prioritizing the right loan for closure can save you money, reduce your debt burden, and improve your financial health. This guide will help you evaluate factors and choose the best strategy to close your loans effectively.

Understanding Loan Closure

Loan closure refers to fully repaying the outstanding balance of a loan, thereby ending your financial obligation to the lender. There are two ways to close loans:

  1. Regular Loan Closure: Paying EMIs as scheduled until the loan tenure ends.
  2. Pre-Closure (Foreclosure): Repaying the entire outstanding balance before the tenure ends.

If you have multiple loans, deciding which one to pre-close first depends on several factors like interest rates, loan tenures, and your financial priorities.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Loan to Close First

1. Interest Rates

  • Loans with high interest rates cost more over time. Closing these first can save significant amounts in interest payments.
  • Examples: Credit card debt, personal loans.

2. Loan Tenure

  • Short-tenure loans can be cleared quickly, freeing up resources for other debts.
  • Long-tenure loans accrue more interest, so closing them early might save money.

3. Loan Type

  • Unsecured Loans: These, like credit card debt or personal loans, often have higher interest rates and no collateral. They should typically be closed first.
  • Secured Loans: Loans like home loans or car loans are backed by collateral and usually have lower interest rates. These can be deprioritized unless they cause significant financial strain.

4. Prepayment Charges

  • Some loans have penalties for pre-closure. Check your loan agreement for details before deciding.

5. Tax Benefits

  • Certain loans, like home loans and education loans, offer tax deductions under sections 80C and 80E of the Income Tax Act in India. Retaining these loans might make financial sense if the tax benefits outweigh the interest cost.

6. Credit Score Impact

  • Closing loans positively impacts your credit score as long as you’ve made timely payments. Ensure the loan closure is reflected accurately in your credit report.

7. Emotional and Financial Stress

  • Loans that cause the most financial or emotional stress should be prioritized for closure to reduce your burden.

Strategies to Decide Which Loan to Close First

1. High-Interest Loan First (Debt Avalanche Method)

  • Focus on repaying loans with the highest interest rate first, while making minimum payments on others.
  • Why? This approach saves the most money in interest over time.
  • Ideal For: Credit card debt, personal loans.

2. Smallest Loan First (Debt Snowball Method)

  • Pay off the smallest loan first, regardless of interest rate. Use the freed-up funds to tackle the next smallest loan.
  • Why? Provides psychological motivation by showing quick progress.
  • Ideal For: People who need motivation to stay consistent.

3. Close Unsecured Loans First

  • Unsecured loans like personal loans or credit card debt have no collateral but often come with high interest rates.
  • Why? Reduces liability and risk of default.

4. Prioritize Loans Without Tax Benefits

  • Close loans that don’t provide tax deductions, like personal loans or credit card debt, before loans that offer tax advantages (e.g., home loans or education loans).

5. Consider Emergency Preparedness

  • If a secured loan (like a car loan) puts your asset at risk of repossession due to missed payments, prioritize closing it to safeguard your property.

Steps to Close Loans Effectively

  1. List All Loans
    Compile a list of all your loans, including:

    • Outstanding balance
    • Interest rate
    • EMI amount
    • Loan tenure
    • Prepayment penalties
  2. Assess Financial Priorities
    Decide if your goal is to save on interest, free up cash flow, or reduce stress.
  3. Evaluate Costs and Benefits
    • Calculate the total interest you’ll save by pre-closing a loan.
    • Weigh this against prepayment penalties or the loss of tax benefits.
  4. Make Extra Payments Strategically
    Direct any surplus income toward the loan you’ve prioritized for closure.
  5. Close Loans One by One
    Focus on fully closing one loan at a time to simplify your financial obligations.
  6. Monitor Your Credit Report
    After closing a loan, check your credit report to ensure it reflects the loan as “closed.”

Example Scenario

Imagine you have the following loans:

  1. Credit Card Debt: ₹1,00,000 at 18% interest.
  2. Personal Loan: ₹2,50,000 at 12% interest.
  3. Home Loan: ₹20,00,000 at 8% interest.

Recommended Strategy:

  1. Pay off the credit card debt first (highest interest rate).
  2. Focus on the personal loan next.
  3. Continue regular payments for the home loan (lowest interest rate and offers tax benefits).

Conclusion

Deciding which loan to close first depends on your financial situation and goals. High-interest loans and unsecured debts should usually take priority, while tax-benefit loans can be managed over their tenure. By adopting a strategic repayment plan, you can save money, reduce debt, and work toward financial freedom.

FAQs

  1. Should I close all my loans at once?
    No, it’s better to prioritize and close one loan at a time for better financial control.
  2. Is it better to close short-term or long-term loans first?
    Closing high-interest long-term loans can save more money over time, but short-term loans may free up cash flow faster.
  3. Does loan closure improve my credit score?
    Yes, closing a loan positively impacts your credit score if payments are made on time.

For more tips on loan management and financial planning, explore our blog for expert advice!